On November 3, 2026, Advocate General Maciej Szpunar delivered his opinion in Case C-250/25, Like Company v Google, which the Court of Justice’s press release No 155/26 calls “the first generative AI case to reach the Court of Justice”. Like Company, a Hungarian web portal operator, sued Google before the Budapest Regional Court, claiming that Google used its articles to train the Gemini models and reproduced and made them available through the Gemini chatbot between June 13, 2023 and May 31, 2024. The Hungarian court referred four questions under the 2019 Copyright in the Digital Single Market Directive.
On training, the Advocate General advised the Court to declare the two training questions inadmissible as hypothetical, because there was no evidence Like Company’s articles were used to train Gemini and because training is not an “online use” of press publications. For completeness, he suggested that using protected works to train an LLM is, as a rule, freely permitted under the text and data mining exception in Article 4 of the directive.
On chatbot answers, which use retrieval-augmented generation to pull news from the web in real time, he took a different line. Whether such reuse falls under the publisher’s reproduction right depends on two factors: whether the chatbot accessed the article unlawfully, for example by circumventing a paywall or anti-scraping measures, and whether the answer merely reports facts or reuses the article’s form of expression so recognisably that the user no longer needs to read the original. The making-available right is, as a rule, infringed where that expression is systematically recognisable in answers. The chatbot provider is liable where such uses are inherent to its business model or where it has not put in place credible measures to counter them.
Why it matters: this is the first view from within the EU’s top court on generative AI and copyright. It separates training, which it treats as broadly allowed under the TDM exception, from retrieval-time reuse of news, which it says can infringe. That split lands on AI search and answer engines rather than on model training.
What it does not show: an Advocate General’s opinion is not binding. The judges have only begun deliberating, and the Court may decide differently or decline to address training at all. Nothing in the opinion finds that Google actually infringed; that is for the Hungarian court to decide.